'Red hot deals' don't always live up to the hype – Consumer NZ

Flashy sales don't always live up to the hype, Consumer NZ says.

We've all been tempted by a "Mega Deal", "Price Smash", or a "Red Hot Deal".

But according to Consumer NZ, some of the country's biggest retailers are making it increasingly difficult for shoppers to tell whether they're actually getting a bargain.

The watchdog tracked the prices of 13 products across five major retailers over a 12-week period, examining how sale prices and promotional language were used.

"There may be a discount, but it's not perhaps as good as consumers are led to believe," Consumer NZ research lead Rebecca Styles said.

She said retailers risked breaching the Fair Trading Act if customers were misled.

Here are the rankings, based on how easy it is for shoppers to spot a genuine sale.

1. Briscoes

Briscoes came out on top.

Consumer NZ ranked Briscoes number one because its sale prices were generally clearly cheaper than usual prices.

Researchers found prices regularly returned to full price between promotions, and Briscoes used less promotional language than its competitors.

"What sets Briscoes apart from the other stores is that prices don't fluctuate as much," Styles said.

That doesn't mean Briscoes always had the lowest prices.

Consumer noted a Ninja air fryer it tracked fell to $125 at Briscoes, while the same product later dropped to $97 at Noel Leeming.

2. Farmers

Some of Farmers' pricing labels could leave shoppers confused, Consumer NZ says.

Farmers placed second, but Consumer NZ said some of its pricing labels could leave shoppers confused.

One washing machine carried a "great price" label throughout the entire 12-week tracking period, despite the price ranging from $1248 to $1669.

Consumer found a similar issue with a Samsung heat-pump dryer, which was labelled a "great price" at both $1399 and $1989.

3. JB Hi-Fi

JB Hi-Fi's "Red Hot Deal" was more expensive than the "On Sale" price tag.

At JB Hi-Fi, a Breville Barista Express coffee machine was advertised as "On Sale" at $600.

Weeks later, the same machine appeared as a "Red Hot Deal" at $698 and also $848.

While each represented a discount from the product's highest tracked price, Consumer said the labels gave little indication of how much shoppers were actually saving.

4. Harvey Norman

Harvey Norman's reduced its use of promotional labels following criticism.

Consumer NZ said Harvey Norman had reduced its use of promotional labels since being criticised in a similar investigation last year.

However, it still found examples where labels were attached to prices that were not necessarily the best deals available.

A handheld garment steamer was $34 cheaper when it wasn't labelled a "hot deal", while an air fryer was $10 cheaper when it wasn't promoted as a "birthday deal" or "hot deal".

Styles said constant promotions can make it difficult for shoppers to know what a product's normal price actually is.

5. Noel Leeming

Noel Leeming was at the bottom of Consumer NZ's rankings.

At the bottom of Consumer NZ's rankings was Noel Leeming, who was "heavy-handed" with sale promises.

"It's impossible to know which promotional label represents the biggest opportunity to save," Styles said.

One example involved a Breville coffee machine advertised as a "Mega Deal" for $869.

Consumer NZ said that was the highest price it recorded for the machine during the 12-week study.

"The mega deal was actually a meagre deal," Styles said.

Noel Leeming chief executive Jason Bell said the coffee machine regularly featured in promotions and that the "Mega Deal" price was still among the best available on the market at the time.

Bell also rejected Consumer NZ's suggestion the promotion could breach the Fair Trading Act.

"We are confident this is not a breach of the Fair Trading Act or misleading, as it was just positioned as a deal, we did not claim a specific saving."

Other retailers had not yet responded to questions from 1News.

Why are these labels so effective?

Shoppers looking for bargains.

AUT marketing lecturer Dr Jessica Vredenburg said sales language is designed to create excitement and urgency.

"Some of these words, some of the colours that come along with it actually activate the reward centres in our brain," she said.

"So you feel like you've won something if you've gotten a deal."

She said shoppers often don't know the usual price of big-ticket items such as appliances and electronics, making it harder to judge whether a promotion genuinely represents good value.

Consumer's advice

Consumer NZ's advice is simple – don't rely solely on the sales pitch.

"One thing consumers can do is actually track the prices of things they've got their eye on," Styles said.

The watchdog recommends using price-tracking tools and comparing prices across retailers before making a purchase.

It also says shoppers shouldn't assume major sales events such as Black Friday automatically offer the lowest prices of the year.

"Sometimes the language doesn't actually match the level of saving that people are getting," Styles said.

SHARE ME

More Stories