A man told his family to lie that he couldn't come to work because he was injured when he was actually in prison, then brought a claim of unjustifiable dismissal against his employer.
David Skelton was on remand for months and his employer NZ Steel spent weeks trying to contact him to find out why he wasn't at work.
Meanwhile, Skelton tried to get his father to arrange long service leave for him.
Eventually, the company deemed Skelton - a long term employee at an Auckland plant - had abandoned his job. The steelworker then took his case to court - and also argued he should receive a redundancy payment after his plant was subsequently shut down.
But in a ruling this week, the Employment Court threw out his case, saying: "an objective bystander would reasonably conclude that Mr Skelton had abandoned his employment".
Arrested
The course of events began on May 25, 2020, when Skelton left work early after struggling with an injury he sustained the day prior and was in "too much pain".
That evening, police arrested him, and he was remanded in custody at Mt Eden Prison, where he remained until September.
Unaware Skelton had been arrested, his supervisor Brendon Quinn was "concerned" and spent multiple days trying to contact him, but got no response.
When another employee suggested the police may know of Skelton's whereabouts, human resources manager Megan Bell was told he was "not in police custody" and NZ Steel should have "no concern".
Police told Bell Skelton "might not be back at work for a while" and the company "needn't try to contact him".
A few days after arriving in prison on May 29, Skelton called his father asking him to request long service leave from NZ Steel on his behalf. This was entered in his timesheets while awaiting approval from his superintendent. The long service leave was never approved.
When Bell and the superintendent spoke to Skelton's father on June 2, he claimed his son was at home with a broken jaw, could not talk, and was waiting to undergo surgery.
He requested three weeks' leave for his son and was told to provide a medical certificate so the company could "tidy up the paperwork".
A doctor's note was never provided, and NZ Steel tried to contact Skelton multiple times for an explanation of his absence.
The court heard that Skelton, who was an operator at NZ Steel's Pipe and Light Plate Plant – a "physical role" that required him to be on-site, told his father to lie about why he wasn't at work.
On June 16, another family member - Skelton's son Keen - initially told NZ Steel a shoulder injury was stopping his return to work, then said Skelton was on remand.
The court heard Keen told Skelton's bosses that his father knew about the letters, had money to make calls from prison, but chose not to contact NZ Steel.
Collective agreement
The company decided Skelton had abandoned his employment under a clause in the collective agreement with the union stating employees absent for more than five days without explanation could be treated as having abandoned their jobs.
Skelton claimed his dismissal was unjustified, arguing he had not abandoned his employment and had sought long service leave through his father.
He maintained that NZ Steel knew, or should have known, where he was.
Skelton also argued he should be paid redundancy compensation after NZ Steel announced the closure of the plant where he worked.
NZ Steel argued that Skelton had been absent for weeks without honestly explaining why and relied on the collective agreement clause for its defence.
Employment Court Chief Judge Christina Inglis found Skelton had ways to communicate from prison and did not honestly tell his employer where he was.
"The evidence shows that he could communicate with the outside world and did so at various times, by telephone and in writing, and through his father, son and lawyer.
"The information communicated to NZ Steel on 3 July 2020 showed that Mr Skelton was aware that NZ Steel wanted him to make contact and explain his absence, that he had the ability to contact NZ Steel, but that he chose not to.
"On those facts, an objective bystander would reasonably conclude that Mr Skelton had abandoned his employment."
The court also found his leave had never been approved, just entered into his timesheet.
Justice Inglis rejected his redundancy argument as his employment had already ended before the process began.
She also noted that if Skelton had been honest about his situation, he may have kept his job, pointing to another employee remanded in custody who communicated with NZ Steel and returned to work.
The court dismissed Skelton's challenge and ruled in favour of NZ Steel.






















SHARE ME