Environment
The Conversation

El Niño shifts Pacific cyclone risk east – what it means for NZ

6 mins ago
Sea temperatures are well above normal in the eastern Pacific Ocean.

Tropical Cyclone Xavier, which strengthened while moving near parts of the northern Cook Islands, reminds us cyclone season is underway in the Southwest Pacific.

By James Renwick for The Conversation

But the system’s location, east of where many Pacific cyclones typically develop, also hints at how this season could look different to others.

With a powerful El Niño taking hold, scientists expect cyclone activity to shift further east, exposing some island communities to greater risk while reducing it elsewhere. So, what does this mean for New Zealand?

Why cyclone risk is shifting east

Tropical cyclones are enormous, rotating storms that develop over warm oceans. Like giant atmospheric heat engines, they draw heat and moisture from the sea, releasing energy as water vapour condenses into clouds and rain.

Tropical cyclone damage in Australia

This fuels powerful winds, torrential downpours and sometimes devastating storm surges.

They typically form in the Southwest Pacific between November and April.

This season, Earth Sciences NZ anticipates seven to 11 named cyclones, compared with a long-term average of nine.

At least four could become severe, reaching category 3 or higher.

But the more interesting part of the forecast is geographical.

While normal to reduced activity is expected in the western Southwest Pacific, risk is elevated near and east of the International Date Line.

This season, tropical cyclone risk is elevated in the east of the Southwest Pacific and reduced in the west. (Source: Earth Sciences New Zealand / CC BY)

Much of this comes down to El Niño, when unusually warm waters develop across the central and eastern equatorial Pacific, accompanied by changes in atmospheric circulation and rainfall.

One important feature is the South Pacific Convergence Zone (SPCZ), a broad band of cloud and rainfall stretching from around Papua New Guinea towards French Polynesia.

It helps determine where cyclones form and travel. During El Niño, the SPCZ tends to shift northeastwards, towards the equator.

Think of this as opening a door.

As the convergence zone shifts, cyclones can develop and travel farther east, increasing the exposure of islands in the central and eastern Pacific, including French Polynesia.

Meanwhile, the Coral Sea, traditionally a major cyclone breeding ground, can experience reduced activity.

During La Niña, the opposite phase of the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO), warmer waters and favourable conditions tend to be concentrated farther west, shifting cyclone activity towards the western Pacific.

Why New Zealand is different

Given the strength of the current El Niño, we might expect New Zealand’s cyclone risk to change too. Yet it’s been placed at near normal this season.

On average, at least one ex-tropical cyclone passes within 550km of New Zealand each year. Some seasons bring none, others several. That’s because getting a cyclone here requires several atmospheric ingredients to come together.

First, the storm needs to be in the right place. In the tropics, cyclones generally move westwards, carried by the trade winds. But as they move south, they encounter the prevailing westerlies and typically curve eastwards.

If that turn happens too far east, near the International Date Line, the cyclone will likely miss New Zealand. To reach Aotearoa, it generally needs to begin that turn further west, somewhere between Australia and Fiji.

Then the mid-latitude atmosphere needs to cooperate.

A trough or low-pressure system moving through from the Southern Ocean can interact with the cyclone, potentially reinvigorating it.

 Farm land is seen flooded on February 14 in Gisborne.

The westerlies must also be strong enough to steer the storm towards New Zealand, but not so strong that they rapidly sweep it eastwards.

As cyclones leave the tropics, they undergo extratropical transition, becoming a different type of weather system. But that doesn’t necessarily make them harmless.

Some of New Zealand’s most damaging storms, including Bola in 1988 and Gabrielle in 2023, involved these transformed systems.

I sometimes compare the process to a pinball machine. A cyclone reaches the edge of the tropics like a ball poised at the top of the chute. A small change in atmospheric circulation can send it in a completely different direction.

This makes seasonal predictions difficult. Even when scientists examine past years with similar conditions, known as analogue years, no two seasons are identical.

What about climate change?

Although warmer oceans and air can provide more energy and moisture for cyclones, that doesn’t necessarily mean more storms.

Research generally points towards fewer tropical cyclones globally, but a greater proportion reaching high intensities, with heavier rainfall and potentially more destructive impacts.

Rivers are more likely to have lower levels and algae while beaches will be hit by bigger swells and wind-blown sand. (Source: 1News)

The relationship between climate change and El Niño and La Niña is less straightforward.

Evidence suggests the rainfall extremes associated with these events are intensifying. Regions that become wetter during El Niño can experience heavier rainfall, while areas prone to drying can face more severe droughts.

Very strong El Niño events could also become more frequent as the planet warms, although questions remain about how climate change will alter ENSO’s overall behaviour.

For New Zealand, a near-normal cyclone outlook shouldn’t be mistaken for low risk.

Earth Sciences New Zealand expects the likelihood of an ex-tropical cyclone affecting New Zealand to be greater in late summer and autumn than before Christmas, with northern and western areas potentially more exposed.

Historically, February and March have been particularly active months for systems approaching New Zealand. But cyclones can develop quickly, and even a weakening storm can bring damaging winds, heavy rain and dangerous seas.

So, whether people are heading away for a summer holiday or camping by the coast, it’s worth keeping an eye on the forecast. As Xavier is reminding communities in the northern Cook Islands, cyclone season is here.

James Renwick is a Professor of Physical Geography (Climate Science) at the Victoria University of Wellington

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons licence.

SHARE ME

More Stories