Outgoing finance minister and National deputy leader Nicola Willis says the "genie is now out of the bottle" on MMP reform, warning an overhang this large would have to prompt questions about electoral system changes.
Willis, one of Christopher Luxon's closest colleagues and main faces of National, will not return to Parliament after the election due to the party's lack of any list MPs.
She said it was “hard for me to see” herself coming back to politics, but she stopped short of closing the door on a comeback in an interview on Q+A today.
Speaking to interviewer Jack Tame, Willis said nobody had foreseen an overhang on this scale when New Zealand signed up to MMP.
The overhang could reach 11 seats or more once final results are released later this week.
“The genie is now out of the bottle. I don’t think when we signed up to MMP in its current form that anyone was envisaging an overhang this large, and so realistically, that is going to provoke questions about what tweaks [or changes] may be required."
On provisional results, there’ll be 131 seats due to overhangs from both sides of the political spectrum. (Source: 1News)
Willis said the electoral system had become a "distraction" during the campaign.
“Ideally, in an election, what you’re debating are the issues of the day and where parties stand on them and the reforms required for the future, but we spend a lot of oxygen talking about whether the system could be gamed, how it could be played, what the strategy for voting should be, and as I say, that’s ultimately a distraction," she said.
"I wouldn't want that to continue and to detract from the other important debates we need to have as a country."
Asked if MMP had to change, she said: “That’ll be for this Parliament ... to grapple with.”
While Willis stopped short of calling for changes to MMP directly, her comments add a senior National voice to the pressure for change.
They come after more than 40 academics, electoral experts and others signed an open letter calling on the new Parliament to fix MMP’s settings this term.
Preliminary results would give the second-placed party six more MPs than the party with the most party votes, and another party five times the number of MPs its party vote would entitle it to, the letter noted.
Qiulae Wong is preparing to lead at least seven MPs into Parliament, none of whom has served before. (Source: 1News)
“Parties and voters will see the success of these disproportionate results and will work to counter any benefit the other side has accrued by using their own tactics,” it said.
The signatories called for an urgent select committee inquiry with MPs from all parties.
‘Don’t close the window’
Meanwhile Willis said former colleagues had urged her not to rule out a return while she was still in a “rebound period” after spending much of her career in politics.
“It’s very hard for me to see right now that I would return to politics. That doesn’t seem likely to me,” she said, but said she felt sadness “for the future that won’t be there”.
"I'm really conscious there's so many ways we can all contribute to the country, and that I can contribute, and I'm really committed to exploring those options.
“But I’ve been advised by many of my colleagues and former colleagues, don’t rule it out straight away. You’re in the rebound period. Don’t close the window immediately. Take some more time for reflection. You're in a stand-down period. No major decisions. I’ll take that advice from people who’ve been here before, and not completely close the door.”
The result has occurred five times since MMP voting was introduced in 1996 but it's getting more attention than ever. (Source: 1News)
Willis, who had been an MP for eight years, said she still had “so much more to offer”.
"It's hard for me to see that I'll be coming back. But you've definitely not seen the last of me. I will be making a contribution to New Zealand," she said.
"I've learned so much in the time I've had in Parliament. I have so much more to offer, and I'm not someone who wants to go quietly into the night. I like to work hard. I like to be busy. I like to take on big challenges, and so I'm excited about what they may look like."
Tax cut reflections
Meanwhile, Willis was also pressed on her now-short-lived record as finance minister.
Luxon was previously confident she would continue in her role in a prospective second term of his government, but her party's failed strategy to see her elected to Parliament in the first place has left her with what National itself would deem a half-finished job.
Asked whether, with hindsight, she would have delivered Budget promises such as tax cuts in the same way — given a weakening economy and unexpectedly deteriorating government books when she took office — she said: “Well, naturally no."
The party's finance spokesperson released its fiscal plan this afternoon as it continues to beat the drum on restraint for spending. (Source: 1News)
"I think the reality of politics is that you can't do a hypothetical about, 'well, if you hadn't campaigned on this.' Actually, at the core of trust between voters and their representatives is the commitments you make on the campaign trail."
She rejected the suggestion that National had promised tax cuts too early in the campaign three years ago. Willis said breaking those campaign commitments “would have been a very bad start to government," but she did have other regrets.
“I do wish that we’d done more to highlight just how downgraded those forecasts had become. They were so different from the pre-election picture that had been presented to us,” she said.
“I think if we’d done more to shape those expectations, it may have made latter decisions easier for New Zealanders to understand.”
Q+A with Jack Tame is made with the support of New Zealand On Air



















SHARE ME