A group of 46 experts wants politicians to urgently consider improving the MMP electoral system, to avoid undemocratic elections in future.
By Russell Palmer of RNZ
Their open letter - led by Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Max Rashbrooke - is titled "Keep the 'P' in MMP" and points to the 11-seat overhang indicated by the initial results, putting the proportionality the 'P' stands for at risk.
"I don't think it's how people want MMP to work," Rashbrooke told RNZ. "People should be speaking out on it and trying to underline for MPs the urgency of tackling it, and try and find a bipartisan solution."
Geddis said the four-seat overhang for Te Pāti Māori was the result of a deliberate campaign to expand influence well beyond its party vote entitlement, and despite campaigns calling for the same thing National's seven overhang seats were "more like an organic result of the National Party continuing to do reasonably well in individual electorates, while its party vote fell off".
Overall, the result distorted representation in Parliament, and he pointed to the '78 and '81 elections that delivered National governments despite Labour winning more votes. That mismatch was "one of the reasons we actually shifted to MMP".
"The overhang could well deliver the same outcome, where you have three parties that have a majority of the seats in the House, but receive fewer votes across the country than the other four parties in Parliament.
"Not really the way democracy is supposed to work, and it's definitely not the way MMP was supposed to work".
The overhang has left Parliament bigger, the balance of power uncertain and the next Government hanging in the balance. (Source: 1News)
Rashbrooke warned it could also become the norm in future.
"Now that people have seen that it is at least possible to engineer an overhang the very real likelihood is that next election that will just become an arms race," he said.
The open letter warned this could lead to disillusionment and lower trust in democracy, and suggested setting up a dedicated select committee to tackle the problem and put solutions in place.
Geddis said while some would argue politicians should not be the ones designing electoral systems - "like allowing panel beaters to design intersections, they are going to do so with their own best interests in mind" - there was a need to get the problem fixed before the next election, leaving little time for a broader discussion.
"We've only got three years ... if we get a Parliamentary select committee doing the thinking about it, it'll help MPs come to realise what the best solution is rather than having an external examination which then has to go to Parliament."
The letter suggested options for fixing the overhang problem:
- Add more list seats so that Parliament would get bigger, to make up for any overhang
- Reduce the number of electorates which would reduce the number of possible overhang seats
- Remove electorate seats from parties that win too many overhang seats by (in line with Germany) requiring parties to have enough party votes to cover their overhang wins, perhaps allowing one or two overhang seats per party
- Only have one vote, so that electorate-based votes also count as party votes, electing both a local MP and contributing to a party vote that could bring in additional list MPs
- Change how votes in Parliament work so that it's based on the proportion of party vote, rather than the number of MPs

One campaign for such a strategy at the election led by billionaire Harry Mowbray explicitly aimed to undermine MMP, which he called a "complete dog" because it ensured power for minority voices.
However, Mowbray himself preferred something resembling the supplementary member system, which would be less representative and guarantee outsized influence from electorates.
"There's an irony there," Rashbrooke said, "that some of the people who are trying to engineer a situation where MMP becomes less proportional, and then argue that's a weakness in the system, are also people who want an electoral system that is much less proportional than MMP."
Geddis agreed.
"Harry Mowbray's criticism of MMP seems slightly confused ... he thinks it gives smaller parties too much power, and the way that he sought to undermine MMP was to show smaller parties how they could get more power."
He said he was not sure such campaigns were successful, but the real risk was future elections would become less policy, more about tactical voting strategies.
"There's no such thing as a perfect electoral system. There's always going to be pros and cons to any change."
On provisional results, there’ll be 131 seats due to overhangs from both sides of the political spectrum. (Source: 1News)
The open letter also highlighted the three public referendums New Zealand had held on the electoral system - in 1992, '93 and 2011 - all favouring MMP.
Rashbrooke said there was no need to throw the proverbial baby out with the bathwater.
"The problem with any system other than MMP is it will be less proportional, it will do a worse job of translating what people actually want into seats in Parliament ... we have discovered there is a weakness in it, that weakness needs to be fixed.
"A bit like the case of: you've got a perfectly solid house, it's a really good house but you've just discovered that there's a little vulnerability in it ... something that needs to be patched up, something that needs to be mended - but the foundations are all totally secure."
An independent review following the 2011 referendum had also called for overhang seats to be abolished, and despite changes to the electoral system - including in both the most recent terms of Parliament, one led by National and one by Labour - politicians have never tackled that or a number of other recommendations.
Neither Geddis nor Rashbrooke believed the major parties could be blamed.
"The fixes that were proposed in the past were fixes for a much smaller problem that you know wasn't quite as pressing. This time around, we can see what the problem is, we can see its magnitude, and we can predict that it's likely to recur in the future," Geddis said.
Rashbrooke pointed to the 1986 Royal Commission on Electoral Reform's finding that "accidental deviations [from proportional results] are most unlikely, and that any attempt to deliberately manipulate the system would be both difficult to implement and likely to attract an electoral backlash".
"I didn't see this coming ... it's crept up upon us," Rashbrooke said. "I'm not sure that I would blame anyone very strongly for not seeing that coming, I think the point is just now that the problem is staring us in the face. We have to do something about it.
"I suspect they didn't think that it would be a problem ... it's not in the nature of the National Party to assume that they're going to get a really low party vote and have a whole lot of overhang seats. You know, that's not how National's ego works, if you like."
The morning's headlines in 90 seconds including a shaky wake up for the south, and a grim end for a Melbourne Cup runner. (Source: 1News)























SHARE ME