Convicted double murderer Scott Watson has been denied parole for the sixth time, but the parole board indicated he has taken steps toward his release.
By Keiller MacDuff of RNZ
At the conclusion of Thursday's hearing, the board told Watson they believed he still posed an undue risk to the community after 27 years in prison.
But board member Alan Hackney told Watson the board agreed he was in the re-integrative phase of his sentence, and scheduled another hearing for July 2027.
The 55-year old has spent 27 years behind bars after being found guilty in 1999 of the murders of Ben Smart and Olivia Hope.
The Blenheim friends, aged 21 and 17, were last seen stepping off a water taxi onto a stranger's yacht in Endeavour Inlet the early hours of 1 January, 1998.
Their bodies have never been found. Police said Watson murdered the pair, dumping the bodies in Cook Strait. Watson has consistently denied the charges and still maintains his innocence.
Watson made several unsuccessful applications to appeal his convictions before a 2017 bid for a royal pardon was granted, with the case heard by the Court of Appeal in 2024.
That court turned down the appeal last year, finding no miscarriage of justice in relation to forensic evidence from Watson's yacht or in the identification of Watson by water taxi skipper Guy Wallace.
In March, the Supreme Court of New Zealand granted Watson leave to appeal the decision in part - specifically on the issue of Wallace's identification of Watson in a police photo montage.
After spending nearly three decades in prison for the notorious sounds murders, the parole board was concerned about his ongoing violent behaviour. (Source: 1News)
The decision in the case, which was heard last month, has been reserved.
A parole bid in January was declined after the board viewed CCTV footage from 2024 of Watson attacking another prisoner, though his lawyer said the incident had been misrepresented.
At the time, the board suggested Watson undertake further treatment to address his attitudes to violence and women, have an Autism Spectrum Disorder assessment and work on his safety plan before reappearing.
Members of the board and a representative of the Department of Corrections acknowledged the progress Watson had made at Thursday's hearing, congratulating him on the work he had put in.
Watson, wearing a grey tracksuit, thanked his support people and the parole board, and expressed empathy for the victims.
His lawyer Kerry Cook KC told the board Watson was not an undue risk to the community, referencing three safeguards that would support his re-integration.
Parole conditions, the stability of the family address Watson would be paroled to, and "the protective effect of his steadfast maintenance of his innocence, which gives him every reason to stay beyond reproach" would ensure his release could be managed safely, Cook said.

Updated specialist reports including a neuropsychological assessment and risk evaluation found Watson posed a low-to-moderate risk of further violence, Cook said.
The reports noted Watson's reserved emotional presentation reflected long-term institutionalisation rather than anti-social intent.
Watson had a minimum security classification, had tested negative for drugs, had a carefully constructed safety plan and was "respectful and compliant with staff instructions", he said.
It appeared the board had concerns about Watson speaking to the media, but that could be managed via parole conditions, Cook said.
The home of family members he could be paroled to provided structure and certainty, combined with further reassurances from electronic monitoring. The genuine family support offered "something no agency can - familial oversight and accountability from people who care about you doing well", Cook submitted.
If the board wanted a more structured transition, such as sending Watson to Leimon Villas - the low-security self-care units at Christchurch Men's Prison - Cook requested it give a firm finding and formal referral.
The lack of a structured timeline for such a transition so far had left Watson "bogged down in some very Kafka-esque scenarios", Cook said.
He believed Watson's reduced risk level, "exemplary custodial conduct" and strong support network meant he should be paroled directly to the community.
Hackney agreed the latest psychological report from Corrections had "painted that similar pathway" of Leimon Villas or other transitional accomodation.
Watson told the board he'd had a "good year", which he put down to the treatment he'd had, productive work with his psychologist and developing his safety plan, which he said he used constantly.
Hackney asked Watson what had been going through his mind during the 2024 assault caught on CCTV.
"Before I started working with [the psychologist], I'd sort of given up, I'd lost a bit of hope in the whole process..." Watson said.
Hackney recognised the progress Watson had made since then but foreshadowed that the board would want to see him doing well for a longer period in a wider range of situations, "Something like the Leimon Villas and potentially [work release programme] Release-to-Work, that level of re-integration."
He asked Watson about the section in his safety plan on his attitudes to women, especially in relation to inappropriate comments he made to a woman while working outside the prison.
"I put that part in my safety plan to show the New Zealand Parole Board that I had thought about what I done, what I said, and I know not to do it again, that I'd learnt from it and that it's just a lot easier to be more respectful ... and that to be disrespectful is just lazy."
He was also asked about letters he had exchanged with a female prisoner, as well as another woman in the community.
Watson identified meeting up with other former prisoners as the most likely cause of him returning to prison, saying the mere fact he had been in prison for so long meant he knew a lot of ex-prisoners.
He spoke of his desire to live a quiet life, away from people, and said if he did meet people from his past, he would tell them he could not associate with them.
A senior Corrections officer told the board Watson had had a good year from a custody perspective.
He told the board the self care units would provide good opportunities for Watson, though noted his high profile could complicate some reintegration activities.

The officer also told the board it had been more than a year since anyone from Christchurch Men's Prison had been on a Release-to-Work opportunity.
"It's been incredibly difficult, so I'd be unsure how realistic that is."
Cook called Release-to-Work "a mirage".
One of Watson's support people told the board no-one in his family or wider group of supporters was under any illusions about how difficult it would be for Watson to reintegrate after such a long time.
"Obviously it's a very different world than the one he left 27 years ago."
She said the family had a plan put together to help manage his release and reintegration.
Asked by board member Gemma Rogers about his risk of re-offending, Watson told her he had a low risk of reoffending.
"I've grown up. I was an arrogant person once. I've just had enough of this. I've had enough of being in prison."






















SHARE ME