New Plymouth councillors vote to rip up 'Tim Tam' cycleway

8 mins ago
Tricia Thompson.

The New Plymouth District Council has voted to rip out its controversial cycleway after little more than a year.

By Robin Martin of RNZ

At an extra-ordinary meeting, councillors adopted a mayoral recommendation to tear up the bike lane — nicknamed Tim Tam Alley after the shape of its concrete separators — between Morley Street and Belair Avenue over the school holidays.

Completed in July 2025, motorists complained of damaging tyres against the concrete separators, home owners struggled to access driveways and businesses bemoaned the loss of parking spaces.

Even cyclists were divided on its merits, some enjoying the security it offered while others felt it was too narrow and a few even had accidents after clipping the separators.

Mayor Max Brough, who made removing the cycleway a focal point of his 2025 election campaign, said he would be pleased to see the back of them.

New Plymouth Mayor Max Brough speaks at an extra-ordinary council meeting about the removal of the cycleway's concrete separators.

"It's always nice to fulfil a campaign promise, but I think what's important to me is that the people who've been asking for this to be done for a long time have finally been heard.

"I didn't come here to make a big shout about how good I feel. I came here to do some stuff round town for people and this is just one part of many."

It would cost the council up to $300,000 to remove the concrete separators and reinstate a painted on cycle lane.

The work would require approval from the Transport Agency (NZTA) - which installed the cycleway at a cost of $3.8 million - and was not budgeted for.

Council staff warned the elected members if the road surface was damaged during the Tim Tams' removal NZTA - which was not contributing to their removal - might require it to be resealed at an estimated cost of $1.6 million.

Brough said if that scenario played out the cycleway would be staying put.

"There's a contingency in that $300,000 for damage repairs, but if it fails drastically the work will be ceased. I am not spending a penny more."

His recommendation also included a provision for council to investigate the reinstatement of parking places lost during the installation of the cycleway as part of the long-term plan process.

This was an acknowledgement that reinstating car parks would require more design work as some earlier car parks might fall foul of new legislation requiring vehicles to allow 1.5 metres for cyclists.

Councillor David Bublitz - deputy mayor when the cycleway went in - wanted removing the cycleway also to be considered as part of the long-term plan.

"My new motion was around doing it all together. So, if we're going to remove the Tim Tams and we're going to put parking back in, because parking will definitely be part of it, we might as well do the roading markings all together. Rather than putting in the cycle lanes and then thinking about where are we going to put the carparks."

His motion was not allowed.

New Plymouth businessman Shane Devlin campaigned against the cycleway from its inception and helped collect a petition with 7500 signatures before it was built.

Co owners of Graphix, Shane and Sharon Devlin.

He gave a deputation at the beginning of the meeting and was thrilled with the eventual decision some four hours later.

"This should've been done a year ago. It's terrible it's carried on this long, but at least we've got some common-sense and we can move forward and get our street back again."

Devlin wasn't concerned about a potential rates impact.

"I think the need of the community is far more important and I don't see how it's a problem for rates because they've only got so much to spend and they are not going to add 1% to rates just because of the Tim Tams."

Devon Street resident Gary Brown also made a deputation.

He explained he'd had trouble accessing his property with traffic often backing up behind him.

Brown was also having trouble selling his home.

"I'm trying to sell my property and I make no secret of this that the real estate agents have advised us that there's a strong public perception that they won't want to buy properties along our side of Devon Street because of the Tim Tams."

Tricia Thompson, who described herself as a cycling grandmother, made a impassioned plea for the cycle lanes to be retained.

"I want the cycle separators to remain because they keep it safe for cyclists. So, even though they are not perfect, they are a separator, so don't take away what is there, add more."

North Taranaki Cycling Advocates Group member, Scott McWilliams, also gave a deputation.

He described a recent $200,000 trial of alternative separators on the cycleway as a lost opportunity because it had failed to capture useful data.

He said the councillors would have to have "rocks in their heads" if they voted to pull out functioning infrastructure and risked making New Plymouth a laughing stock.

Following the decision, McWilliams said he could live with the decision because he was a confident cyclist but he felt for others.

"The Tim Tams make it safer. I'm disappointed for people who might be new to cycling and looking for a way into it. I'm disappointed for those who don't have a car, who can't afford a car and are being deprived of a safe access route to commute from Whalers Gate, Spotswood into town."

McWilliams said there was well documented evidence that cycle infrastructure had economic benefits as well as being more environmentally friendly.

Keen cyclist and gym-goer Jeff Allan had a different take.

Still bearing the marks of his misfortune, he shared with councillors how his pedal clipped a Tim Tam as he looked over his shoulder causing him to crash, leaving him injured to the point where he hadn't ridden his bike in months and was only now returning to the gym.

SHARE ME

More Stories