Punch-up between staffer and young person at youth justice facility

16 mins ago
Youth justice residence Korowai Manaaki (file image).

A punch-up between a staff member and a young person took place in a youth justice facility in September, RNZ can reveal.

By Lillian Hanly of RNZ

It comes a year after a "reset plan" was undertaken at the facility - Korowai Manaaki - to lift standards.

Official documents seen by RNZ show a staff member antagonised a rangatahi (young person) during a table tennis game, making a hand gesture indicating they were breaking something across their knee.

This was taken to mean his head, and he then challenged the staff member to a fight.

They unlocked the door to the courtyard where the pair were then seen "adjusting their stance and raising their fists in what appeared to be preparation for a physical altercation".

They then exchanged blows before another staff member intervened and stopped the altercation.

When the pair stopped fighting, they were then seen shaking hands and hugging each other. The staff member sustained a bloody nose, which was possibly broken.

The staff member was escorted offsite, access was removed, and official documents stated they would not return.

The young person later said he was surprised the staff member had followed through and did not expect it.

Police attended the incident at the time, and had photographed the injuries.

Acting Detective Inspector Martin Bienvenu, Counties Manukau CIB told RNZ inquiries were underway following the report of an alleged assault "to understand the full circumstances surrounding the incident".

Labour's spokesperson for children Willow-Jean Prime said it was "yet another harmful incident" at the same facility.

The incident occured the same month RNZ revealed staff were present during the assault of a young person by his peers in a ritual attack known as 'walking the line' at Korowai Manaaki earlier this year.

"We need clear answers about how staff are being trained to de-escalate situations and why incidents involving staff continue to occur," Prime told RNZ.

Minister for Children Karen Chhour wouldn't comment on the employment issue, given it was operational.

Korowai Manaaki is seen as a "challenging residence" partly due to the cohort of young people it has, according to Oranga Tamariki (OT)'s head of youth justice and residential care Dean Winter.

Official documents also showed - like other residences - it was seeing increasing complex needs and behaviours, more serious offending behaviours, and a higher proportion being sentenced to longer periods on remand by the youth courts.

Chhour has consistently pointed to training undergone to make improvements across youth justice, part of that was a specific reset for Korowai Manaaki.

RNZ asked Chhour whether the training and developing of Youth Justice (YJ) residence staff was working as she hoped.

Chhour said the improved training programme was an important step towards better practice, "but I acknowledge that it will take time to embed".

"This training is just one part of Oranga Tamariki's efforts to fix long-standing issues stemming from a previous lack of standard operating procedures and adequate training at these facilities.

"I am confident that once these efforts are fully implemented, they will significantly improve the safety of young people and staff."

12 week reset plan

Youth justice residence Korowai Manaaki (file image).

Korowai Manaaki is the largest YJ facility in New Zealand, providing care for up to 42 young people aged 14-19.

OT said it had "unique challenges" as a residence, and external reviews and observations by leaders had identified consistent themes which needed to be addressed, "namely leadership visibility, culture and practice, and improved security and safety provisions".

Poor standards in secure care had also been noted - these were units where young people were placed for short periods if they were likely to cause harm to themselves or others.

In Budget 2025, $40 million was allocated over four years to the professionalisation of the workforce, with the money held in contingency. RNZ has requested the amount spent so far on training.

In March, Chhour told Prime in a written parliamentary question she had been advised by Oranga Tamariki performance at Korowai Manaki was being monitored on an ongoing basis following the reset plan. She said positive changes included improved staff engagement, strengthened processes and improvement to infrastructure.

RNZ requested information about the reset plan itself, which took place in late 2025.

The "intensive intervention" was designed to "stabilise operations, strengthen capability, and lay the foundation for lasting cultural change".

Official documents from Oranga Tamariki showed the main risk of the plan was that "change will not embed".

Over 750 training sessions and assessments were completed, across modules including professional standards and workplace integrity, standard operating procedures, secure care essentials and leadership training.

At the completion of the reset, OT acknowledged some harm was still occuring on site, but practice in managing complex dynamics and reducing risk of violence had improved.

A post-reset report from December noted staff had raised frustrations with management and policy consistency, staffing gaps, low morale and a desire for more recognition through pay and rewards, safety and voice.

In June this year, Chhour was asked by Prime whether she was satisfied with the management of Korowai Manaaki, to which she said "absolutely".

Chhour added there'd been a decrease in incidents occuring under her watch.

"I'm absolutely proud of the work they've done.

"Not saying it's perfect, not saying that some things don't go wrong."

SHARE ME

More Stories