Only the most blinkered Welsh fan would have seen victory coming in Cardiff on Saturday night, but with it, the All Blacks have conceded another of rugby’s great records. As Scotty Stevenson writes, that’s what will hurt the team, and its fans, the most.
On Friday night in Paris, a depleted French side outlasted the Springboks to claim a 20-18 victory, temporarily thwarting the South Africans' aspirations to reach the Nations Championship final in two weeks’ time and opening the door for the All Blacks to take top spot.
On Saturday night in Cardiff, an unheralded Welsh team breathed their terrible fire and bared their terrible teeth and ended seven decades – and change – of waiting for a win over New Zealand. New Zealand still went top of the Nations Championship southern table. Wales remain in fifth spot in the north.
The two top ranked teams in the world were indeed shown up. South Africa beaten by a team forced to use the world’s best halfback at first five, and the All Blacks by a team that, by almost all objective assessments, should have been lucky to get within 30 points.
Elsewhere, Australia fell to a fourth consecutive defeat, this time to Scotland, Japan were given a hiding by England, and Fiji were given a lesser hiding by Ireland. Argentina’s win against Italy was the sole southern light in the tier one battle of the hemispheres.
The team stunned the All Blacks 35-28 in Cardiff. (Source: 1News)
Why this loss matters
The All Blacks were one of five southern hemisphere teams to lose a nations championship fixture over the weekend. The others shrug the shoulders, take it on the chin, and move on. That’s not something an All Blacks team gets to do. That’s not something this All Blacks team gets to do. That’s why this loss matters.
Objective assessments, indeed. These are the rare minerals of the punditry world, and in the wake of Wales’ shock victory, one has been forced to mine at ever greater depths to find them.
It is hard to be objective when a team that markets itself on win rate – the most dominant professional sports team in the history of the world, ever – somehow manages to fall prey to a team that had snuck past Japan a week ago and hadn’t beaten a genuine top-flight nation in three years of trying.
So here goes: an objective assessment.
All Blacks fans hate losing, but they hate losing records even more. They didn’t like being bundled out of the World Cup in the quarterfinals for the first time in 2007 (incidentally, in Cardiff), they sure as heck didn’t like losing to Ireland for the first time in 2016 (weirdly, in Chicago), and they didn’t like losing to Argentina for the first time in 2020 (in, *checks notes, remembers Covid* um, Sydney).
Each of those losses was felt more deeply because it wasn’t just a team losing a game, it was a nation losing a narrative. “[INSERT COUNTRY HERE] have never beaten the All Blacks” was a sentence New Zealand rugby people revelled in hearing on television bulletins and reading in print. It was the accompanying throughline to every build up to a match against Ireland (until it wasn’t), and against Argentina (and now it’s not), and against Scotland (sorry, Scotland, that one still applies).
Wales had a different story, of course, but their own brand of despair was measured first in years, then in decades, then in the constituent parts of a century. Fifty years went by, and 75 years was just around the corner. Until…
If New Zealand had a psychological advantage over certain rivals (and Wales, for so long, seemed one of them) you could at least understand why: History is not a hurdle, it is a burden.
Wales were no strangers to the excess baggage charges whenever they pitched up to face the men in black. That baggage was loaded with hopes and dreams, torment and heartbreak, final quarter capitulations, the space between the rest of the lineout and Andy Haden’s sprawling body, Gareth Thomas’ point at the posts, the boots of Clarke and Karam and McCormick and McKechnie, and the echoes of a haka in the visitors’ sheds.
You can pack a lot in 26,628 days.

The scent of victory and fresh hope
That so many Welsh sides featuring so many Welsh legends had tried and failed since that December day in 1953 to earn their own famous victory against New Zealand only made the weekend’s events at the Principality Stadium harder to fathom.
Take nothing away from Steve Tandy’s charges, but it’s hard not to look at the television pictures of Gareth Edwards in the grandstand at fulltime, and not raise a befuddled eyebrow at the other, metaphysical, Gods of the game.
Wales tackled their way into global rugby folklore at a time when Welsh nationalism and self-determination are back on the agenda and the Welsh language is enjoying a renaissance of its own.
Here were the sons of Wales: Dewi, Daffyd and Tomos among them, framed by the Dragon’s breath and hell bent on – as Lewis Valentine put most eloquently in his Welsh hymn Dros Gymru'n Gwlad – bringing "the day when God’s breeze blows again over our withering acres".
If Welsh rugby gazes upon those withering acres – and it’s abysmal finances and wretched regional infighting shows how barren this once fertile land has become – this performance was indeed God’s breeze, one perfumed by the scent of victory and fresh hope. From now on the All Blacks have not beaten Wales since 2026.
Now for the other objective assessment.
The All Blacks resisted the temptation to make wholesale changes through the South African series and, indeed, during the two Bledisloe Cup matches. They did not wish to tinker more than necessary against Scotland.
Wales, by virtue of being the weakest opponent in the November series, was chosen as the assignment to test the depth of the squad. It was a bet, one hedged with experience in key areas. It was a bet that has not paid out. At least not immediately. Some might say it was a bet that backfired big time.

Perspective is the first casualty of an All Blacks’ loss, and perspective is required here. In a year’s time the All Blacks could be world champions and may point to a Saturday night in Cardiff as the genesis for that ultimate triumph.
Was it the All Blacks’ worst performance of the year? Or was it a loss made more painful for what was actually lost? Another bragging right gone, another crack in the edifice of the All Blacks’ intimidatory brand story. Ireland, then Argentina, and now Wales, slinging rocks from handmade trebuchets.
The South Africans, meanwhile, will lick their Parisian wounds and carry on unencumbered by the outrage of defeat that attaches itself now to this All Blacks squad. For them, a world cup cycle ends in a World Cup Final, not a team building Test match at the Principality Stadium.
Perhaps in the world cup era, All Blacks fans may have to quiet-quit the win percentage obsession, if it means a first Webb Ellis Cup in 12 years. Of course, All Blacks fans won’t do that. And nor will the All Blacks themselves.
That win percentage is what made this team the force it is, and why they can ill afford to falter again this weekend in London. A World Cup is not on the line, yet, but New Zealand is playing for much more already.






















SHARE ME