Fonterra has alarmed environmentalists with a proposal to dump up to 22 million litres of raw milk in Canterbury - the equivalent of almost nine Olympic-sized swimming pools.
By Keiller MacDuff of RNZ
The dairy giant said the move was necessary to manage a potential surplus caused by production constraints across the South Island. The company would not be drawn on what the production constraints were.
Federated Farmers welcomed the proposal, calling it a sign of prudent risk management.
Fonterra's applications to vary the conditions of seven resource consents were filed with the Canterbury Regional Council on October 2. They relate to wastewater discharges at its Clandeboye, Darfield and Studholme sites in Canterbury.
The variations were sought as a contingency response to surplus raw milk that Fonterra anticipated during the peak milk period in the 2027 and 2028 financial years, but, if granted, would apply for the duration of the original consents, which range from 2027 to 2045.
In its technical memorandum to the council, Fonterra said it anticipated "surplus raw milk will require disposal during the peak period of FY27 due to processing constraints that may occur across the South Island", and estimated the volume would be approximately 22,340m3 (22 million litres) over the current season.
A Fonterra spokesperson said the consent variations would allow the co-operative to dispose of milk when events "out of its control" prevented it being processed.
"We deal with a perishable product that needs to be processed within 24-36 hours," they said.
The spokesperson said Fonterra had similar provisions in other consents across the country.
The company had not needed to dispose of milk this season and was already through the peak processing season (late-October to mid-November), nor did it foresee having to dispose of milk next season, the spokesperson said.
"Work done across our network during winter this year has helped to ensure that we have enough capacity to efficiently process all our milk," they said.

If needed, Fonterra could shift processing to the North Island or adjust the products it made, the spokesperson said.
"With 24 manufacturing sites across the country, we have considerable flexibility to manage our farmers' milk. If those options were exhausted, we have contingency arrangements for the safe and appropriate disposal of milk, including on farm, where necessary," they said.
New Zealand's milk production set a new record in the 2025/2026 season, processing 2.02 billion kilograms of milk solids, a 4.5% increase on the previous season, from 21.8 billion litres of milk.
DairyNZ's latest figures showed the South Island had higher average milk solid production per cow and per hectare compared to the North Island, while North and South Canterbury had the biggest average herd sizes and stocking rates in the country.
Infometrics puts the average number of cows in the Canterbury region at just over 970,000 in the year to May, an increase of 2.1% over the year, double the nationwide increase of 1%.
The Canterbury Regional Council has granted effluent consents allowing for up to 57,000 more cows since a temporary freeze on dairy conversions expired in January last year.
Fonterra's application stated the surplus raw milk would be incorporated into existing wastewater systems or applied directly to land. Either way, the milk would end up on farmland after being mixed into the wastewater streams and irrigated onto pasture, or loaded straight into tankers and spread onto or injected into soil.
Raw milk contained the same substances as the consented wastewater, including organic matter, fats, protein, nitrogen and phosphorus but at "significantly higher concentrations", the application stated.
The company advised any environmental effects were considered to be "no more than minor".
Milk dumping would also have "positive effects" by adding extra capacity for surplus milk and "allow beneficial re-use of nutrients and organic matter", contributing to soil fertility and supporting pasture and crop growth, the application said.
The variations were consistent with the regional council's objectives and policies, including the Canterbury Land and Water Regional Plan, and neither public nor limited notification of the consent variations were required, Fonterra argued.

'An extraordinary volume of food to waste'
The Environmental Law Initiative (ELI) called on the regional council to reject the application.
Senior researcher Anna Sintenie said the group was concerned by a "vast" change in activity from the original consents and the scale of the proposal.
"We're looking at beforehand discharging wastewater related to processing of trucks and plant facilities' wash down. What's been proposed here is a completely different substance of raw milk and the scale of that is huge," she said.
"Twenty-two million litres is more than four litres of milk for every person in New Zealand. That's an extraordinary volume of food to waste, especially with so many households experiencing cost-of-living pressures.
"It also comes at a significant environmental cost, including greenhouse gas emissions, heavy freshwater use and nutrient pollution."
The council should require Fonterra to submit new consent applications, which had higher notification and analysis requirements than variations, Sintenie said.
"Fonterra is trying to shoehorn a major discharge of raw milk into existing wastewater consents through a variation. In our view, that's not acceptable. A discharge of this kind should require a full, new consent application and proper public scrutiny," she said.
ELI was also concerned about regional council dairy conversion approvals that had green lit consents associated with tens of thousands of additional cows in the past year, Sintenie said.
"That raises a fundamental question: why is the region continuing to expand dairy production when Fonterra is seeking permission to dispose of surplus milk because production is likely to exceed its processing capacity?"
The environmental footprint of 22.3 million litres of milk included about 20,000 tonnes of emissions, approximately 6.5 billion litres of freshwater (mostly for irrigation and stock water) as well as many billions of litres more to dilute nitrate pollution, she said.
Sintenie said the application also requested the definition of wastewater be amended to include raw milk.
"By applying for this, it would open the door to that happening in these consents into the future. It's concerning that it could set a real precedent about how we think about incorporating this hugely valuable and nutrient-rich food product into wastewater," she said.
Canterbury regional council general manager of regulatory implementation Paul Hulse said the council became aware of Fonterra's processing constraints in late September.
He said the council "do not and cannot take business constraints into account" when assessing consent applications.
Hulse said it was not for the council to say whether the application should have been lodged as new consent rather than a variation.
"Fonterra is entitled to submit the applications in the form it considers appropriate. Our role as regulator is to determine whether the proposed changes fall within the scope of the existing consents," he said.
Asked what effect large amounts of raw milk could have on the environment, Hulse said the council's water and land science team would "assist consents planners in evaluating an assessment of environmental effects for the proposed activity".
'Good, prudent business practice'
Federated Farmers national dairy chair Karl Dean said he was not aware of similar attempts to allow milk dumping but welcomed the move, calling it "good, prudent business practice".
He said there were a number of scenarios that could require milk to be disposed of, such as following an earthquake.
"It was a matter of making sure the appropriate systems and risk mitigations are in place so that if something bad did happen, the options are there - even if they never get used - that those options are available," he said.
"I think what this highlights to me in doing some research is it's a bit concerning that some of the other milk processors don't have that ability in their consents."
"Obviously, I would expect the cooperative to be ... wanting to utilise every drop of milk which I'm sure they will. I think this is more of a case of making sure that good risk management is in place so that should the absolute worst happen, that there's allowance to do something."
Dean also supported Fonterra's attempt to have the definition of wastewater changed to include raw milk, which he said would be beneficial for the entire industry.
Federated Farmers understood most South Island production constraints had already been mitigated, with significant upgrades to several sites in the South Island over the last year.
"As a farmer, I haven't been impacted this year the same way I was impacted last year when there was some issues, so I'd say that those mitigations have obviously worked," he said.
In September, Fonterra announced it would spend $1 billion over three years on its South Island manufacturing network.

Concerns over Canterbury's waterways
Greenpeace freshwater campaigner Rhiannon Mackie said dumping raw milk could have harmful environmental impacts.
"Canterbury has highly porous soil, which means it's really easy for fluids to get through the soil and into water tables like we see with the cow urine and synthetic fertiliser that causes nitrate contamination," she said.
"In lakes and rivers in particular you can see increases in toxic algal blooms, which are already an issue in Canterbury, and have a really negative impact on the health of the freshwater ecosystems," she said.
"Not only are New Zealanders subsidizing the dairy industry through the pollution of drinking water and lakes and rivers, we're also paying huge amounts of money at the supermarket for dairy products and meanwhile Fonterra is talking about dumping these raw milk products because they've just got so much of it," she said.
According to Fonterra's "conservative assessment scenario", the co-operative would send the bulk of the surplus milk (60%) to the Clandeboye site, near Temuka - an indicative volume of 13,404m3 (13 million litres per season or 600,000 litres per day) - although it noted actual volumes could vary depending on milk supply, processing capacity and operational requirements.
The next largest amount (37% of the total) would go to Darfield in the Selwyn district - 500,000 litres per day - while 3% (25,000 litres per day) would be disposed of at Studholme near Waimate.
A recent Journal of Dairy Research paper quantified dairy food loss in New Zealand for the first time, finding the industry routinely lost 1.8% of dairy food on farm and 5.5% at the processor.
The study said the loss was "not a sizable issue" but equated to the annual milk production of approximately 86,000 cows on farm and 264,000 cows at the processor.
Victoria University research fellow Dr Mike Joy said the even the routine dairy losses had a big impact.
"You can call that minor if you like, but that's equivalent to 350,000 cows worth of milk that's just discarded. To me, that's criminal, that's not minor, that's a massive impact," he said.
Research led by Joy in 2022 concluded each litre of milk produced required up to 11,110 litres of water to dilute nitrogen leached from Canterbury dairy farms.
He dismissed Fonterra's stance the effects of the dumping on the environment or to neighbours, residents and groundwater users would be "less than minor".
"Every application claims the impacts are less than minor but the cumulative effects of a whole heap of less than minors is major," he said.




















SHARE ME